Department of Clinical and Experimental Medicine, University of Pisa, Pisa, Italy.
Leonardo Massoni
Tel: 3339692418;
Email: lmassoni700@gmail.com
Received : Feb 01, 2024 Accepted : Mar 15, 2024 Published : Mar 22, 2024 Archived : www.meddiscoveries.org
It is known that Folic Acid (FA) plays an important role in normal brain development and functions. Interest is growing about the implications of folic acid employment in neuropsychiatric disorders. This work reviews the literature available from 2018 to 2022 on the biochemical and clinical correlates of FA administration in cognitive diseases such as Autism Spectrum Disorders (ASD), Attention Deficit-Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD), and Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder (OCD). It was found that FA supplementation is a safe and promising therapeutic strategy to mitigate the symptoms of these diseases.
Keywords: Folic acid; Cognitive disorders; ASD; ADHD; OCD.
Folate is a member of the vitamin B family, essential for production and mainteinance of homocysyeine at non-toxic levels in new cells, as well as for nucleotide and neurotransmitter synthesis, DNA and histone methylation reactions, myelin synthesis [1]. From a biochemical point of view, dietary folic acid is metabolized to tetrahydrofolate that is activated in one-carbon unit to 10-formyltetrahydrofolate, 5,10-methylenetetrahydrofolate, and 5-methyltetrahydrofolate that, in turn, supports a biosynthetic pathway for the synthesis of purines and thymidylate and the remethylation of Homocysteine (HC) to methionine. Synthesis of methionine requires 5-Methyltetrahydrofolate (MTHF) and vitamin B12. Folic acid is converted to dihydrofolate and then tetrahydrofolate by dihydrofolate reductase, that is dependent on NADPH [2].
The potential of folic acid in psychiatric disorders is largely known and folate has been found that to be safe, with no risks for adverse effects [2]. In addiction, blood folate levels can be easily assessed. A correct maternal folate status is essential for brain development and functioning of offspring. Particularly, animal models show morphological, physiological, and genetic alterations in offspring as a consequence of prenatal or postnatal exposure to irregular levels of folate. Human studies indicate a positive correlation between sufficient maternal folate status and offspring cognitive function [3].
The importance of a regular folate intake during pregnancy even for mother’s mental health emerged from a recent work. The authors reported a possible link between Methyltetrahydrofolate Reductase (MTHFR) C677T mutation C677T mutation and post-partum psychopathology including psychosis, bipolar and unipolar disorders, thus suggesting that that these variants may influence. Interestingly, this mutation is known to be implicated in psicotic disturbances, bipolar and unipolar disorders, folate level and symptoms of postpartum psychopathology, and suggesting that these variants may influence folate metabolism and be implicated in depression during pregnancy [4].
Cerebral Folate Deficiency (CFD) in adults is relatively common. A study examining clinical and radiological aspects of patients with CFD before and after folinic acid supplementation highlighted the importance of CSF 5MTHF dosage in patients with mitochondrial diseases, primary brain calcifications and unexplained complex neurological disorders [5].
Folate deficiency is reported in different neuropsychitric diseases [6,7]. A meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials examined the efficacy and safety of adjunctive folate for schizofrenia, bipolar disorder and major depressive disorder. It has emerged that for schizophrenia adjunctive folate is not superior to placebo in terms of total psychopatology, while for bipolar and unipolar depression it is superior to placebo in the acute phase of mania but not in improving depressive symptoms [6].
In line with the relevance of folate in neuropsychiatric disorders, the role of levomefolic acid or 5-methylfolate acid supplementation has been analysed, especially as an adjunct pharmacotherapy, in improving some clinical variables. The authors pointed out significant effect of this supplementation not only for schizophrenia and mood disoders, but also for autism spectrum disorder and attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), with minimal side effects [7]. Moreover, the importance of folic acid for the prevention of Alzheimer Disease (AD) is largely reported. Polymorphisms in MTHFR [8,9] as well as folic acid deficiency [10,11] and subsequent alterations in folate pathways [12,16,17] can be associated with cognitive disturbances. Meantime, folic acid supplementation has been proven beneficial in people with cognitive impairment [10,18], even in haemodialysis [16]. Therefore, given the frequent assessment of blood folate levels, the aim of the present review is to analyse literature on the possible relationships between folic acid blood levels and some neuropsychiatric disorders and to comment on the possible therapeutic role of this vitamin supplementation.
Search strategy: According to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines, we manually searched eligible literature for this systematic review. We carried out this work through PubMed from 2018 to 2022 with the following search items: 1) folic acid and neuropsychiatric disorders; 2) folic acid and autism spectrum disorders; 3) folic acid and obsessive-compulsive disorder. Furthermore, we manually added other articles to the selection by screening the bibliographies of the eligible articles.
Selection criteria
Inclusion criteria: Articles were included if written in english and they satisfied one of the following study designs: clinical study, clinical trial, comparative study, controlled clinical trial, multicenter study, observational study, randomized controlled trial, systematic review, and meta- analysis. We also decided to include studies carried out in animal models.
Data extraction: Data were abstracted using a predefined data extraction form: first author, publication year, study design, sample size, basic information of participants (gender, age), diagnosis, criteria for the assessment of the mood disorders, specific biomarker alterations.
Folic acid and cognitive disorders: Three studies have investigated MTHFR genes polymorphisms in animal models. One of them showed that polymorphisms in the 5,10 MethyleneTetrahydrofolate Reductase (MTHFR) genes are associated with high risk for developing late-onset AD by affecting the Amyloid-β Protein Precursor (AβPP), a protein with a crucial role in neurodegenerative disease [7]. Particularly, MTHFR knockout mice present increased cortical and hippocampal AβPP phosphorylation at the regulatory Thr668 site, that, in turn, enhances accumulation of demethylated protein phosphatase 2 (PP2A) and glycogen synthase kinase 3β(GSK-3β). All these mechanisms contribute to alter neuronal homeostasis, thus highlighting a possible linking between dietary folate deficiency and risk of sporadic AD [7]. A MTHFR polymorphism thought to be implicated in the late onset AD is the MTHFR 667 C>T polymorphism.Two groups of mice, wild type and Mthfr (a model for the MTHFR 667C>T polymorphism) were fed control or folate-deficient diets from weaning until 8 and 10 months of age. Those with Mthfr +/-genotype presented altered transcriptional levels of synaptic markers and epigenetic enzymes, reduced levels of S-adenosylmethionine and acetylcholine, thus suggesting how genetic and dietary folate metabolic disturbances increase risk for cognitive decline [8].
Folate seems to play a role in preventing senescence through alleviation of telomere attrition. Senescente-Accelerated Mice Prone 8 (SAMP8) were divided into 4 experimental groups: FAdeficient diet group (FA-D group), FA-normal diet group (FA-N group), low FA-supplemented diet (FA-L) and high FA-supplemented diet (FA-H) group. There was also a Senescent-Accelerated Mouse Resistant (SAMR1) control group (Con-R) and a young SAMP8 control group (Con-Y). It was found that FA supplementation delayed age-related cognitive decline and neurodegeneration in SAMP8 mice thanks to alleviated telomere attrition and in turn, to lower levels of reactive oxygen species [15].
Moreover, chronic folate deficiency has been shown to induce lipid and glucose metabolism disorders in murine models. The authors enrolled seven-week-old mice which were fed with either a Chronic Folate Deficiency (CFD) and a control diet for 25 days. Except from glucose intolerance and increased triglyceride levels, after 24-week diet treatment, CFD induced anxietyrelated activities and impairment of spatial learning and memory performance, thus highlighting the relationship between CFD and cognitive deficits [10].
Five studies examined effects of folate on neurocognitive problems in humans. Another biochemical mechanism implicated in folate good effects in cognitive functions is the increase of Hcy. A recent review [14] showed that folic acid could improve cognitive functions by decreasing Hcy, vascular care, attenuating inflammatory status, modificating folic acid deficiency and facilitating antioxidant responses. The authors’s conclusion was that peolple with high levels of Hcy have a better response to folic acid supplementation in terms of improvement of cognitive functions [14]. Starting from the known relevance of Aβ deregulation in cognitive impairment, the combination of folic acid and Docosahexaenoic Acid (DHA) was proved useful in mild cognitive impaired patients. Infact, DHA and folic acid supplementation effect in improving cognitive functions has recently been related to reduction of blood Aβ-related biomarkers in patients with Mild Cognitive Impairment (MCI) [17].
A study, analysing relationship between folate levels and cognitive impairment among individuals with vitamin B12 deficiency, found that the association between low intake of vitamin B12 and folate and cognitive diseases could be mediated by elevation of homocystein and homocysteic acid. Infact, these molcecules have a neurotoxic effect and the consequence of their increase may be irreversible cognitive impairment [13]. Another molecular mechanism implicated in cognitive effects of folate deficiency is the deregulation of mitochondrial function. A case-controlled studied investigated serum folate metabolites and mitochondrial function function in peripheral blood cells of 82 AD cases and the same number of controls, matched by age, gender, and education. AD patients presented lower reduced mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) copy number, higher mtDNA deletions and increased 8-hydroxy-2-deoxyguanosine(8-OHdG) content in mtDNA. From the other side, the authors found that the highest level of mtDNA copy number was associated with a reduction in AD risk, independently of serum folate and Hcy levels. Overall, these results pointed out lower mitochondrial function in peripheral blood cells of AD patients with a folate deficiency [12]. Intriguingly, usefulness of folate supplementation has been proved even in haemodialysised patients with congitive problems [16].
FA in Autism Spectrum Disease (ASD) and Attention-Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD): Nine studies included in our work reported a positive correlation between prenatal maternal folate levels and ASD risk in the offspring [18-26] three of them a negative correlation [27,36,37] and five ones failed to report a significant correlation [28-30,33-35].
Two studies reported significant correlation in animal models [19,25]. The first one focused on periconceptional folate deficiency in murine model of Wistar rat’s offspring. Female rats were divided in two groups: control (with a basal diet) or exposed during one month before breeding until gestational day 15 to a modified diet with no added folic acid, reduced choline and added 1% SST (a non-absorbable antibiotic used to inhibit folate synthesis by gut bacteria). It was found out that offsprings with periconceptional deficit in folate presented congenital body malformations, reduced social interactions, increased anxiety, repetitive behaviors compared to controls. These results support the linking between maternal periconceptional deficit in folate and autistic-like phenotype [19].
A study carried out in rat moldels highligthed that maternal FA supplementation at high doses can prevent growth and development delay as well as deficits in social communication and repetitive behaviors probably thanks to an increase in dendritic spine density and a downregulation of inhibitory ones. The author’s conclusion was that this vitam supplementation may play a key role in preventing ASD [25]. Six studies made on human models reported interesting findings on the role of maternal folic acid supplementation in the pre-conception period and beginning of pregnancy as a protective effect in ASD. [18,20,26,31,24,31]. A work carried out in mothers who used FA in the 6 weeks before and after conception showed protective effect of folic acid supplementation in these mothers compared to those who hadn’t used it. From the other side, it was seen that an excess of FA may result in an increased risk of ASD [18]. Some authors focused on the effects of vitamins in general in reducing ASD risk in siblings of children with ASD in high-risk families and found that maternal prenatal vitamin intake during the first month of pregnancy can reduce ASD recurrence [20].
In line with these findings, 416 ASD children and 201 typically developed controls were analysed for laboratory measures, such as vitamin A(VA), D(VD), B12(VB12), folate and ferritine. ASD children’s mothers presented lower levels of maternal folic acid or micronutrient supplementation during pregnancy. Moreover, these children had more social cognition and communication impairment, autism behavioural mannerisms as well as more severe gastrointestinal symptoms than children whose mothers received regular supplements [26]. A recent systematic review examined the correlation between maternal prenatal folic acid supplementation and ASD in the offspring. Globally, it was pointed out that the consumption of a daily amount of at least 400 micrograms of folic acid from dietary sources and supplements was associated with a reduced risk of ASD in the offspring compared to a control group that didn’t receive this supplementation [24]. Overall, a review and meta-analysis found that even though previous literature suggests that periconceptional use of folic acid is associated with reduced ASD risk [21-23], the global reduction in ASD risk was about the 58%, whereas no effect was registered on mental and motor development [31].
However, five studies failed to find an association between folic acid prenatal levels and ASD risk [28-30,32,34]. From the other side, three works reported negative association between maternal folate levels and ASD risk. In the first one, a group of 1257 mother-child pairs were enrolled and had their maternal plasma folate and B12 levels measured 2-3 days after child birth. It was seen that very high levels of maternal plasma folate at birth (>60, 3 nmol/L) were associated with 2,5 times increased risk of ASD [27]. Similar findings were highlighted by the second study. The authors collected samples from 100 women with ASD offspring and from 100 control women with typically developing children. Concentrations of metabolic biomarkers were determined, including amino-acids, vitamins, biomarkers related to folate, lifestyle factors and PCR. Weak evidence emerged for a positive association between higher maternal serum concentrations of folate and occurrence of ASD. Internal biochemical relations between the biomarkers were confirmed. It was concluded that high maternal serum folate status during early pregnancy could be associated with occurrence of ASD in the offspring [35]. It was proposed a particular interpretation of this eventual increased risk of ASD in case of high-dose gestational folic acid. Starting from the hypothesis that ASD children are more likely to be the first or second born, and that women tend to consume higher levels of folate during their first or second pregnancy, the linking between higher doses of folic acid and ASD could be influenced by this bith order bias[36].
Impairmeint of folate patways in ASD and ADHD may be due to genetic causes [24,38,40,43,57], and autoimmunitary aspects [41,42]. Moreover, a folic acid deficiency was associated with neural [5] and oro-facial defects [39]. Starting from the consideration that ASD is characterized by abnormalities in methionine patways, plasma levels of metabolites in methionine trans-methylation and trans-sulfuration patways were measured in 80 ASD and 73 control children. Moreover, common polymorphic variants known to modulate these patways were evalued in 360 children and 205 controls. Plasma methionine and indicators of methylation capacity, such as S-Adenosylmethionine (SAM) to S-Adenosylhomocystein (SAH) ratio, as well as plasma levels of cysteine, glutathione, and the ratio of reduced to oxidized glutathione resulted decresed in ASD children compared to controls. These findings suggest that clinical manifestations of ASD could be related to increased vulnerability to oxidative stress [37]. A study was carried out in two groups of respectively 89 ASD people and 89 matched controls. Participants were examined for 13 serological metabolites and two genetic variants related to folate metabolism. It was found that folate-related metabolism contributed to ASD and differences between ASD and healthy controls could be found to detect folate-related metabolism biomarkers [39]. A work made in Han Chinese population failed to find an association between genetic causes and ASD. The population was studied for the association between a singleNucleotide Polymorphism (SNP) in genes involved in vitamin B12 and folate and childhood AS; no significant association was found between all these genotypes and ASD risk [38]. Similarly, a review explored genetic causes of ASD and ADHD by investigating the possible role of folate and folate-related patways in neurodevelopmental disorder, such as ASD and Attention Deficit-Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD) [40]. Folate deficiency during pregnancy has been associated with both ADHD [41] and ASD [42]. Some studies reported the MTHFR C677T mutation in ASD as well as the presence of T allele or TT/CT genotypes more commons in mothers of ASD subjects compared to typically developed people [37,43,44,45,21,46,47]. The authors also reported some studies which failed to find an association between MTHFR variant and autism risk [48-50,38]. Moreover, they presented a single work supporting the role of MTHFR C677T polymorphism in ADHD [51]. Another polymorphism found in ASD is the RFC1 A80G [52]. MTRR A66G genotype has been considered an important risk factor for ADHD [53]. The 19bp deletion DHFR was found associated with ASD in an Australian cohort of 17 patients and 16 controls [48,40]. Some works carried out in children with autism spectrum disorders provided an autoimmune explanation of lower levels of folic acid in ASD individuals [54,55]. Infact, the authors found a high prevalence of serum Folate Receptor Autoantibodies (FRAA) in ASD patients, and this may reduce the effect of this vitamin supplementation in pregnacy.
From a therapeutical point of view, four studies-one of them made on murine models [60] - documented the importance of folate supplementation for psychomotor [58], behavioral [59] and social aspects of ASD [61]. A study carried out in BTBR + Itpr3tf/J (BTBR) mice receiving FA (0,2 mg/kg/) orally from postnatal day 14-35 pointed out that FA supplementation could reduce repetitive and stereotyped behaviors, improve social communications, enhanced memory and spatial learning via the downregulation of cell loss in hippocampal CA1 region of the brain and modulated oxydative stress and inflammatory responses by altering the ferropotosis signaling pathways [60]. A study analysing Mexican children for effects of dietary intake of folate and viatamin B12 in mental and psychomotor development showed that dietary folate intake in early childhood may be beneficial for the mental development of children [58]. Another work carried out in 19 ASD children, was made to evaluate the efficacy of folinic acid at a lower dose of 5 mg twice daily in improving Autism score. It was seen that Autism Diagnostic Observation Schedule (ADOS) score, social interaction, communication sub scores were improved at week 12 compared to baseline only in the folinic acid group. The greater change of ADOS global score was noted in the folinic acid group, thus suggesting a possible therapeutic role of folate in ASD [59]. Moreover, beneficial effects of folinic acid as an adjuvant to risperidone for the treatment of inappropriate speech and other behavioral symptoms in children with autism have recently been highlighted [61].
Regarding folate role in treatment of ADHD, it has been questioned if L-methylfolate could augment methylphenidate in the treatment of ADHD. A clinical trial of 15 mg of L-methylfolate in combination with osmotic-release oral system methylfenidate showed that L-methylfolate was well tolerated with an improvement in the ASR scale. Methylphenidate level was higher in individuals treated with L-methylfolate probably due to a variation in a guanosine triphosphate cyclohydrolase gene. All these findings could suggest a possible beneficial effect of L-methylfolate in ADHD [62].
Folic acid in Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder (OCD): The role of folate supplementation in OCD is still quite limited.
A work examined serum folate and homocysteine concentrations in 23 OCD patients and in control subjects. The severity of the disease was assessed through Yale-Brown Obsession Compulsion Scale (Y-BOCS). It emerged that OCD patients presented lower levels of folate, whereas their homocysteine concentration resulted higher. Meantime, methylation and monoamine metabolism were impaired in OCD patients [63]. However, other three studies did not confirm previous findings [64-66].
Authors and year |
Study design | Sample | Diagnostic criteria | Results | Limits | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Patients | Control group | |||||||
N (M/F) | Age±SD | N (M/F) | Age | |||||
Lv et al.2019 [16] | Case-control | 82 Alzheimer Disease (AD) | - | 82 controls | - |
National Institute of
Neu- rological and Communica- tive Disorders and Stroke and Alzheimer Disease and Related Disorders As- sociation (NINCDS-ADRDA) |
D patients with folate
defi- ciency or hyperhomocistein- emia had low mitochondrial function in peripheral blood |
Small sample size, brain tissue and peripheral system are different |
Lu et al. 2021 [15] |
Prospective, randomized, placebo- controlled, double-blind |
115 patients in Main- tenance Haemodialysis (MHD) who had Montreal Cognitive Assessment (MoCA)score lower than 26 and receiving thiamine 90 mg/die combined with folic acid 30 mg/die fol- lowed for 96 weeks |
- |
115 controls receiving thiamine placebo 90 mg/die and folic acid placebo 30 mg/die fol- lowed for 96 weeks |
- | MoCA |
Thiamine and folic acid could reduces homocysteine levels, so as to relieve the oxidative stress and improve cognitive function in patients with MHD. |
Cognitive score measurement by different research- ers may differ in the evalu- ation of cognitive function of subjects in a multicentre study. |
Li et al. 2021 [18] |
Single-center, double-blind, randomized clinical trial (RCT) design |
160(138 completed the trial) patients with Mild Cognitive mpairment (MCI), divided in 3 groups: Folic Acid (FA) (N=35), folic acid+ Docosahexae- noic Acid (DHA) (N=34), DHA(N=36) |
Mean age of FA group= 67, 51±5, 07 years. FA+DHA group=66, 74±5, 79 years. DHA group=70, 17±6,54 years |
Control group (N=33) |
Mean age=68, 30±6, 38 years |
Chinese version of the Wechsler Adult Intel- ligence Scale-Revised (WAISRC). At baseline, the Mini- Mental State Examination (MMSE) |
6 months of
supplementation with 0.8 mg/day folic acid combined with 800 mg/day DHAimproves cognitive func- tion in older adults with MCI. In addition, intervention reduced homocysteine and A_-related biomarker levels, while increasing the SAM/SAH ratio, folate, DHA, and SAM levels relative to those in the placebo group |
Blood biological indi- cators not tested at 6 months after stop- ping intervention. Treatment duration has been short. |
Levine et al. 2018 [19] | Case-cohort |
45300 children (M=23210; F=22090), 572 with ASD. 11917 children born by mother exposed to FA before preg- nancy, 21884 children born to mothers exposed to FA after pregnancy |
10±1,4 years |
International Classification of Diseases, Eighth Revision, and the International Clas- sification of Diseases, Ninth Revision) |
Maternal exposure to
folic acid/ multivitamin supple- ments before pregnancy was associated with a lower likelihood of ASD in the offspring compared to no exposure before pregnancy |
Presence of confound- ings.Small sample size. Lack of information on gestational age decreas- ing the accuracy of exposure classifications |
||
Schmidt et al. 2018 [22] | Prospective cohort |
Younger siblings of ASD
chil- dren (N=241, M=140, F=101) |
Mean age= 36, 5±1, 6 months |
- | - |
Autism Diagnostic Observation Schedule (ADOS), Mullen Scales of Early Learning (MSEL) |
Maternal prenatal vitamin intake during the first month of pregnancy may reduce ASD recurrence in siblings of children with ASD in high- risk families |
Small sample size. The possibility of residual confounding or con- founding by unmea- sured factors cannot be ruled out. |
Raghavan et al. 2018 [23] |
Prospective | 86 ASD children |
Mean age of children mothers= 30,9±6,5 years |
1171 neurotypi- cal children |
Mean age of their moth- ers=28, 3±6,6 years |
EMR (Electronic Medical Record) |
Extremely high maternal plasma folate and B12 levels at birth were associated with ASD risk. |
Diagnosis was made on the basis of EMR. Lack of information about maternal dietary intake data during preconcep- tion and pregnancy |
Vàzquez et al. 2019 [29 |
Systenatic review and meta-anal- ysisis |
756365 children |
Range=11 months to 15 years |
Routine prenatal supplements of folic acid were associated with signifi- cantly lower levels of ASD. |
||||
Guo et al. 2019 [33] |
Systematic review and meta-analysis |
Observational studies (a
total of 13 reports; 840,776 children and 7127 cases) |
This study doesn’t
provide support for the association between maternal FA intake during the prenatal period and the reduced risk of ASD in children |
Small number of studies in literature |
||||
Raghavan et al. 2020 [20] | A prospective cohort | 92 ASD children |
Mean Mothers age=29, 8±6, 2 years |
475 neurotypi- cal controls |
Mean moth- ers age=28, 3±6,4 years |
EMR using ICD-9 and ICD-10 |
Higher concentrations of cord UMFA, but not 5- methyl THF or total folate, were associated with a greater risk of ASD in Black children. |
Diagnosis of ASD made on the basis of EMR. Study limited to a subset of children. Presence of possible confounders. UMFA not measured in maternal circulation. DHFR polymorphism is the only analysed |
Tan et al. 2020 [32] | Retrospective |
ASD children (N=416,
M=333, F=83) |
Mean age= 4,68±1,94 |
Typically devel- oping children (N=201) |
Mean age= 4,47±1,06 years |
DSM-5 |
Children born by mothers without folic acid and micronutrient supplementa- tion during pregnancy had more severe cognition and communication impairment, autistic behavior mannerism, delays in adoptive gross and gastrointestinal than children born by moth- ers who didn’t use FA and supplementation |
Disproportion between males and females |
Santos et al. 2020 [35] | Cohort | 4571 Brazil participants | Range=35-74 years | - | - |
Not found significant
associ- ations between serum folate and cognitive performance in this large sample, which is characterized by a context of food fortification policies and a consequent low frequency of folate deficiency. |
Very few participants had serum folate levels below the WHO cutoffs for folate deficiency. Not included red cell folate and homocysteine. Single determination of folate for each partici- pants |
|
Egorova et al. 2020 [36] |
Case-control group |
100 women with ASD diag- nosed offspring with 76 male children and 24 females |
Median age of mothers=31 years Range=28-34 years |
100 women whose offspring were typically developed with 78 male children and 22 females |
Median=30 years Range=26-33 years |
DSM-IV |
High maternal folate
status during early pregnancy may be associated with the occurrence of ASD in the offspring |
Disproportion between children M/F ratio |
Liu et al. 2022 [30] | Systematic review and meta-analysis |
9795 ASD cases (10 studies
and 23 sub-studies included) |
- | - | - | - |
Folic acid
supplementation during early pregnancy was associated with a lower risk of offspring’s ASD. The con- sumption of a daily amount of at least 400 μg folic acid from dietary sources and supplements, was associated with a reduced risk of offspring ASD. Critical effective maternal folic acid supplementation strategies may aid the reduc- tion in the risk of offspring ASD. |
Detailed information was acquired through questionnaires. Residual or unmeasured con- founding factors are possible. |
Authors and year |
Study design | Sample | Diagnostic criteria | Results | Limits | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Patients | Control group | |||||||
N (M/F) | Age±SD | N (M/F) | Age | |||||
James et al. 2006 [38] | Retrospective | 80 autistic children (M=89%, F= 11%) | Range: 3-14 years, Mean age=7,3±3,2 years | 73 controls | Mean age=10,8±4,1 years | DSM-IV |
Plasma methionine and the
ratio of S-Adenosylmethi- onine (SAM) to S-Adenosylhomocysteine (SAH), were significantly decreased in ASD children relative to age- matched controls. Plasma levels of cysteine, glutathi- one, and the ratio of reduced to oxidized glutathione were decreased. Differences in allele frequency and/ or significant gene–gene interactions were found for relevant genes encoding the reduced folate carrier (RFC 80G>A), transcobalaminII (TCN2776G>C), catechol-O- methyltransferase (COMT 472G>A), methylenetetrahy- drofolate reductase (MTHFR 677C>T and 1298A>C), and glutathione-S-transferase (GST M1). |
Disproportioned M/F ratio |
Ramaekers et al. 2008 [41] |
Retrospective |
ASD patients (N=25, M=18, F=7) |
Median age=6,88 years Range=2,8-12,3 years |
25 controls (M=14, F=11) |
Median age=6,76 years Range=3,3-11,4 years |
DSM-5, Autism Diag- nostic Observation Schedule (ADOS) in conjunction with the Autism Diagnostic In- terview (ADI) |
CSF 5MTHF was low in 23 out
of 25 patients. The re- duced CSF folate in 19 out of these 23 patients could be explained by serum FR autoantibodies blocking the folate binding site of the membrane-attached FR on the choroid epithelial cells. Oral folinic acid supplements led to normal CSF 5MTHF and partial or complete clinical recovery after 12 months. |
Small sample size. Dis- proportion in M/F ratio in the first group |
Zhang et al. 2018 [40] | Cohort |
Han ASD Chinese
population (N=201) |
Healthy children (N=200) |
Childhood Autism Rat- ing Scale (CARS), pa- tients with scores of <36 were classified as mild-to-moderate and 36 as severe. |
Lack of association of all
examined SNPs with
childhood ASD and its severity |
Small sample size.
Absence of M/F stratification |
||
Zhou et al. 2018 [42] | Retrospective |
ASD Children (N=40, M=32, F=8) |
Mean age=3,225±1,476 years. Range=2-6 years |
Typical development (TD) children (N=40, M=32, F=10) |
Mean age=4,309±1,506 years. Range=2-6 years |
DSM-5 |
Serum FRAA are more
prevalent in children with
ASD than TD. Children with ASD may have defects in folic acid absorption. |
Small sample size. Disproportioned M/F ratio in both ASD and controls. |
Zou et al. 2019 [43] | Retrospective |
ASD people (N=89, M=78,F=11) |
Mean age=6,68±2,92 years |
Controls (N=89, M=78, F=11) |
Mean age=6,71±2,95 years |
DSM-5 |
Folate-related metabolism
contributes to
predisposition of ASD. Folate-related metabolism biomarker could be useful both for detection of ASD individuals from con- trols both for early ASD diagnosis |
Disproportion between males and females in ASD people group and in control one. |
Gatica-Domínguez et al. 2018 [59] |
Cross-sectional |
229 children (55% male,
45% female) and their mothers |
Children: 24 months and
32 months. Mothers: 22,2±4,3 years |
Non autistic children |
Dietary folate intake in
early childhood may be
ben- eficial for the mental development of children |
Not significant results. It is possible that the reported associations are conservative es- timate due to random measure- ment error inherent to the food frequency questionnaire used to estimate dietary folate and vita- min B12 |
||
Renard et al. 2020 [60] |
Randomized, placebo- controlled |
19 children receiving
pla- cebo or folinic acid |
- |
19 children receiving
pla- cebo or folinic acid |
- |
Autism Diagnostic Obser- vation Schedule (ADOS) |
The global ADOS score and
social interaction and communication sub scores were significantly improved at week 12 compared to baseline in the folinic acid group but not in the placebo group. A greater change of ADOS global score was observed in the folinic acid group compared to the placebo group. No serious adverse events were observed. |
Small sample size. Absence
of stratification for M/F ratio and for age |
Batebi et al. 2020 [61] | Double-blind, placebo-controlled, randomized |
ASD children receiving
folinic acid (N=28, M=16, F=12) |
Mean age=8,36±1,81 years |
ASD children receiving
placebo (N=27, M=19, F=8) |
Mean age= 7,82±1,84 years | DSM-5 |
Folinic acid dosage was 2
mg/kg up to 50 mg per day for the entire course of the study. The repeated measures analysis showed significant effect for time × treatment interaction on inappropriate speech, stereotypic behavior, and hyperactivity noncompli- ance subscale scores. In contrast, no significant ef- fect for time × treatment interaction was found on lethargy/social withdrawal and irritability subscale scores. The study provided preliminary evidence suggesting that folinic acid could be recommended as a beneficial complementary supplement for alle- viating speech and behavioral symptoms in children with ASD. |
Small sample size,
dispropor- tioned M/F ratio in ASD group receiving placebo |
Surman et al. 2019 [58] |
Randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled |
ADHD adults receiving L- Methylfolate (N=22, M=8, F=14) |
Mean age= 41,3±11,4 years |
ADHD adults receiving
pla- cebo (N=19, M=7,F=12 |
Mean age= 37,7±8,9 years | DSM-IV |
Methylfolate was well
tolerated, with no
significant effect over placebo except improvement from ab- normal measures on the mean adaptive dimension of the Adult Self Report (ASR) scale. Methylpheni- date dosing was significantly higher in individuals on L-methylfolate over time. |
Limited ability to predict
value of biomarkers. Small sample size. |
Authors and year |
Study design | Sample | Diagnostic criteria | Results | Limits | |||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Patients | Control group | |||||||
N (M/F) | Age±SD | N (M/F) | Age | |||||
Atmaca et al.2005 [63] |
Placebo controlled study |
OCD patients (N=23, M=8, F=15) |
Mean age= 29, 1±6, 3 years Range = 18-44 years. |
Healthy individuals (N=23, M=10, F=13) |
Mean age= 27, 2±5, 4 years. Range= 21-44 yeras |
OCD was diagnosed through DSM-IV crite- ria. severity was deter- mined through Y-BOCS scale |
A group of patients with OCD might have folate deficiency, higher homo- cysteine levels and prob- able impaired metylation and monoamine metabo- lism |
Small sample size,
disproportioned M/F ratio in the patient group. |
Dar et al. 2021 [64] |
The study consisted of two phases: a 2-week open-label prospective phase to confirm resis- tance to SRIs and the second 6-week open- label addition phase for non- responders of the first phase |
Patients (N=115, 60 of them were considered resistant and entered in the second phase of the study. At the baseline F=60, M=55) |
Mean age of
females=29,2±10,4 years |
- | - |
DSM-5 criteria were used for OCD diagno- sis. Y-BOCS and CGI scales were used for disease severity assessment |
Methylfolate wasn’t ef- fective in treatment of resistant OCD people |
Long-term tolerability of
adding antipsy- chotics to SRIs in patients with resistant OCD cannot be commented upon while the need of giving antipsychotics for lon- ger a duration is there since high chanc- es of relapse are present on discontinu- ation after a response is seen. None of patients had poor insight of OCD, so it wasn’t possible to comment the effect of antipsychotics for insight. |
Tural et al. 2018 [65] |
Double blind, placebo- controlled |
Patients receiv- ing fluoxetine and folic acid (N=18, M=8, F=10) |
Mean age= 31,06±10,18 years |
Patients receiving
fluoxetine and placebo (N=18, M=6, F=12) |
Mean age= 33,44±11,62 years |
OCD diagnosis was as- sessed through DSM-IV criteria. (Yale Brown Obsession Compul- sion Scale) Y-BOCS was used to detect severity of symptoms. The Hamilton Anxiety Rating Scale (HAM-A) for anxiety. Hamilton Depression Rating Scale for depression. The Clinical Global Impression (CGI) for general improvement or deterioration |
It may be assumed that there is no beneficial ef- fect of folic acid addition to fluoxetine in the treat- ment of OCD |
The study has a relative
small sample, not implemented a dietary restriction, and not used methylfolate the active metabolite of folate |
Yan et al. 2022 [66] |
Systematic reviews and meta-analysis of case- controls studies |
Experimental group (N=172 cases) |
- | Control group (N=137 cases) | - |
Eight databases were used (e., PubMed, Embase, Web of Sci- ence, the Cochrane Library, China Biology Medicine disc, China National Knowledge In- frastructure, Wanfang Database, China Sci- ence and Technology Journal Database), and the retrieval time was up to March 2021) |
The content of folate in the OCD group was not significantly different from that in the control group |
Some articles’ measures data
aren’t dis- tributed normally and weren’t reported in the form of median and quartile. Only English and Chinese language reports have been searched. Small sample size. The results were based on unadjusted estimates, more accurate outcomes would be achieved due to adjustments for other confounding factors. Some factors hadn’t been taken consider into study (e.g., renal function) of partici- pants. One set of trails from the last cen- tury hasn’t mentioned the details about the diagnosis and detection methods. Most of the participants in 1 study were women. There are also some dif- ferences in the laboratory examination methods for each index in each group due to time. |
The present review showed a potential benefit of folates supplementation in neuropsychiatric diseases. Globally, a certain number of studies reported a protective role of folate prenatal regular intake from ASD risk in the offspring [18-26]. Intriguingly, by analysing receptorial profile of some ASD children, endogenous factors of resistence to folate supplementation were detected [54,55], whereas in other ASD individuals beneficial effects of folate supplementation on different aspect of autistic disease, such as stereotyped behaviors and social communication, are largely supported [58,59,61]. We also decided to include in our work the role of folate supplementation in cognitive disturbances [9,17]. Studies made on animal models reported how genetic and dietary folate metabolic disorders increase risk for cognitive decline [9,11]. Meanwhile, a beneficial role of folic acid in alleviating telomere attrition in cells and in lowering levels of reactive oxygen species [15] was higlighted, while works carried out in humans pointed out that folate deficiency may induce a cognitive impairment via decrease of Hcy [68] and blood Aβ-related biomarkers [17]. Indeed, some limitations of the published studies should be acknowledged. Some of the significant findings of folic acid benefits on neuropsychitric diseases were carried out in animal models. Moreover, a great number of studies focused on specific genotypes or polymorphism, thus limiting the extension of these findings to general population, who is not routinely screened for these variants. Sometimes, other intermediate molecules, such as homocysteine, mediated the effects of folate. As a result, that of folic acid was often an indirect effect.
Taken together, the findings derived from the present review suggest into that folic acid supplementation may be a safe and advantageous for the prevention and improvement of different neuropsychiatric disorder. However, the exact role of folic supplementation for prevention of these diseases is still rather unclear and needs to be deeply investigate
Declaration of interest: None.